When it comes to movies, it may be that sex
doesn't sell.
A recent study concluded that nudity and explicit sex scenes don't translate to success for major motion pictures.
"Sex
Doesn't Sell -- nor Impress! Content, Box Office, Critics, and Awards
in Mainstream Cinema" examined more than 900 films released between
2001 and 2005.
The study found that, contrary to popular belief,
sex and nudity failed to positively affect a film's popularity among
viewers or critics and did not guarantee big box office receipts.
One
of the study's co-authors, Dean Keith Simonton, said theirs was the
largest sample of its kind used for film research. The results
surprised him, he said.
"Sex did not sell, whether in the
domestic or international box office, and even after controlling for
MPAA rating," said Simonton, who is a professor of psychology at the University of California, Davis. "In other words, even among R movies, less graphic sex is better."
The
top-grossing films in the study included movies like "Shrek 2;"
"Spider-Man;" "Star Wars Episode III: Revenge of the Sith" and "The
Lord of the Rings: The Return of the King," all of which contained
mostly minor to mild sex and/or nudity.
Simonton said the
research went beyond others in that it also examined other forms of
"objectionable" material that might earn a film an R rating including
violence.
The study was prompted by an experience almost a decade ago of its co-author, Anemone Cerridwen.
Cerridwen
had been taking acting classes and increasingly became uncomfortable
with some of the sexualized content she was encountering. That led her
to consider the work experiences of film actresses and the pursuit of
data about the lucrativeness of sex in movies.
"I assumed sex
sold, and wanted to know by how much," Cerridwen said. "I braced myself
for the worst, and got quite the surprise."
Craig Detweiler,
director of the Center for Entertainment, Media and Culture at
Pepperdine University, said the study's findings reflect the culture's
post-sexual revolution sensibilities.
"Nothing is as shocking
anymore," Detweiler said. "You can see it in Britney Spears' kiss with
Madonna and Janet Jackson's Super Bowl performance. Things that were a
big controversy among some, the next generation kind of yawned at it."
Rather, Detweiler said, he has seen among his students that the new
form of rebellion against the older generation includes "not doing
drugs, not sleeping around and not getting divorced." That might
explain the popularity of some of the Jane Austen films and movies like the "Twilight" series, he said.
"Those stories are really about sexual separation," he said. "They are all about wooing, not winning."
Tom Jacobs, staff writer for the academic research periodical Miller-McCune,
wrote about the study and said there has long been the belief that the
many young males who make up movie audiences are enthralled by female
nudity.
"These researchers really put that belief to the test
and crunched the numbers," Jacob said. "What I took from the study is
that a hint of sex is perhaps more enticing than out-and-out nudity."
The study's authors are hopeful that their findings will have some impact on moviemaking.
Simonton
said he has had one inquiry from a researcher at a major studio that he
declined to name, though he has no idea if the studio plans on acting
on the data.
Cerridwen said she thinks movies continue to be
influential on the public and believes their study could also have an
influence, especially if other academics pick up the torch and continue
the research. Until then, she hopes Hollywood takes notice.
"I
do believe that there are a fair number of people in the film industry
who want to make better films, and this study may give them some
ammunition," she said. "I know that Hollywood has been trying to make
more family-friendly films for a while (since the '90s) and it seems to
be helping ticket sales, so my guess is that this research would
complement that."